The squat is considered by many experts to be the single best exercise for boosting strength, power and size. But which variation is better: the front squat or the back squat? To find out, we asked Ross Edgley, sports scientist at Myprotein.com, to compare them by examining the muscle activation patterns and movement mechanics of each type.
A study at the University of Florida studied muscle activation in 15 trained and experienced athletes as they performed both types of squat at 70% of their one-rep max for three reps. The study uncovered that although the athletes were able to lift 19kg more during the back squat, there was no significant differences in muscle activation of the quads, hamstrings or erector spinae muscles.
Winner: Back squat (marginally)
The same study at the University of Florida found the additional load (19kg) during the back squat increased compressive forces during the lifts, making athletes more prone to injury. This led the researchers to conclude the front squat is better at maximising overall muscle recruitment while minimising injury.
Winner: Front squat
One of the most important muscle groups in the lower body for sport is the gluteal muscles (the gluteus maximus muscle, gluteus medius muscle and gluteus minimus muscle) since they are involved in almost all lower-body movement, either as producers or stabilisers of movement. Australian research found that the wider stance usually used during a back squat was better able to activate the gluteal muscles than the narrower stance of the standard front squat.
Winner: Back squat
The results are in…
The back squat edges it here because it allows you to go heavier and activates more muscle fibres. However, you need to include both in your routine if you want to hit all the muscle groups in your legs effectively. Just remember to start light and get your form correct before you start pushing up through the weights.
Here’s an easy-to-follow guide to squat form. Give it a read before your next squat session. For more on Myprotein products, check out their website and to subscribe to Men’s Fitness, go here, or download a digital issue here.